I’ve been a BMW buyer since 2005. My first car was a leased 3 series. I did not have a
car to trade in, and I agreed to a deal that required a $1,000 down payment and a series
of payments. In retrospect, that car deal worked out great for me and my wife, who
commandeered the car once our first child was born because she felt it was safer that
the other car we owned
Since that initial lease, I have purchased at least 4 more BMWS over the past 20 years. I’ve
gravitated to buying certified pre-owned vehicles, as I felt purchasing a brand new car is
a stretch for me. This blog is about the financing considerations when purchasing a
car, and more importantly the considerations when upgrading into a new
vehicle. I will also point out how I was feeling when making these decisions and speak
to them in a behavioral finance context. I will be using real numbers on a recent deal I
have been considering.
For this discussion, the car that was purchased was a 2018 5 series – bought in June,
2021. I believe it had about 30,000 on miles at time of purchase. I don’t not believe the
manufacturer’s warranty transferred with the car, as it was over 3 years old when I
purchased it (usually the manufacturer’s warranty is 3 years or 36,000 miles). Note here, the warranty on a 2018 BMW 5 series is 4 years/50,000 miles - whichever comes first.
I bought a maintenance plan, as part of my goal back in 2005 was to own a car 'worry free'. If
something went wrong or needed fixing, I’d just take it back to the dealership. I had
spent too many hours waiting in independent garages over the years so, to me, it was
worth making the dealership my partner in the car, at least for the beginning of
its life with me.
So, the initial amount financed is $47,817 – beginning June 12, 2021. That includes all
fees, taxes and also a small balance due from thecar I traded in as part of the
deal.
As of this writing, I have paid a total of $46,800 to drive the car, 50 months of use, and
still owe $6,464.56 on the vehicle. My original thought, and this was a year ago, was to
pay off the loan and drive for a year without car payments. At the time, I couldn’t find a
better car in terms of age and miles, and many cars I looked at had more miles than the
car I was driving, even though they weren’t as old. I am currently rethinking that
strategy, as the car is currently 7 years old and since I no longer have a maintenance
plan, I am on the hook for all repairs. I have received a lot of interest in the car this year
from Carvana and other sources, and I feel I can sell the car for at least $20K. If I
choose that route, I will have $13,500 or so to put down on a new certified pre owned,
which will allow me to start the cycle all over again with a newer car by 4 years and, and
most likely a smaller monthly payment.
Key learnings:
When looked upon on a cash flow basis, I feel the equity in the cash and the balance remaining allow me to enter into this transaction sooner than expected. The benefit is an upgrade of my car car for the same monthly payment, without having to drive my existing car for anther 18 months with the concern over the cost of repairs that can happen over that time.
Effectively, I only paid $34,000 out of cash flow to own the car for 4+ years, which was
below the agreed upon sticker price.
With Carvana, Car Max and other vendors, the dealership is no longer the only game in
town for a trade in. Hence, competition for cars has increased and along with that, the
price for a trade in.
In my interactions with clients over the years, those who want to own their cars often
drive them too long, thereby increasing the cost of ownership via making repairs on an
older car. I’m pretty sure most don’t even keep track of the annual cost of repairs. They
think that because they paid the car off the annual cost of the car is minimal, but since a
car is a depreciating asset, there is always the chance of a repair or costly maintenance
cost, thereby spending and perceived savings of not having a car payment.
Interest rates matter. The 0% financing or 2% financing that existed over the last 20
years certainly made it easier to carry a note on a car - I could argue the increased
price of trade ins these days offsets much of the increase in interest expense incurred on
a loan at current interest rate pricing. Of course, the higher credit score you have, the
better interest rate you should receive from the financing department or bank.
This strategy is for someone who wants to have a relationship with the dealership to
handle repairs without hassle, wants a newer car for perceived reliability and has the
cash flow to keep your options open. I used to drive my cars into the ground, to the
point where any residual value is minimal, and I always felt I was starting over.
After 20 years of experience in financing a luxury vehicle this way, I have found major
repairs to be minimal, as none of the cars ever exceeded 75,000 miles. I figured it was
OK to let someone else run it into the ground, and move into new models and start the
process over time and time again.
I thought about trading in this car a year ago, but at that time the balance on my loan,
the price of the trade and the inventory available at the time led me to keep my current
car. A year later, the numbers seem to have aligned and I will be going to the
dealership to see if I can put this together.
Feel free to contact me to discuss this if you have questions